Both blackout curtains and blackout shades have room darkening potential. While both can block out light, there are specific benefits when choosing between the two. Also, what is the difference between blackout shades and curtains?

While both use blackout roller shade material, curtains hang below the bottom of your window frame and come in pairs to draw around both sides of your window. Shades are sold in multiple lengths and come as a single unit that can roll up or down.

To help you decide the best fit for your home, we will make a pros and cons list of both blackout curtains and shades. By the end of this article, you’ll know which option will suit your home better.

Pros and Cons of Blackout Curtains


Sound Dampening

Manufacturers make curtains using thicker fabric materials. The makeup offers more significant potential noise reduction. If you live in a location known for frequent noise pollution, curtains can help.

Saves on Heating Bill

Thicker materials allow you to control your home’s internal temperature. Because the areas around your window frame are the most likely to leak, curtains are your second line of defense. Think of it as buying a blanket for your home.

Offers a Layered Look

Because curtains go over the window sill, layering has more significant potential. Layering with drapes or other window coverings can add a unique flair to your home. Curtains work well with a variety of window treatments.


Difficult Upkeep

Because curtains touch the floor, they require a bit more attention. If you have kids or pets that like to get in trouble, this can be doubly true. Expect to spend more time cleaning.

Dated Design Choice

Blackout curtains have thick, heavy material. Having a subtle, modern environment, while using large tracts of material. Be doubly sure that the types of blackout curtains you buy don’t clash with the rest of your home.

Not Suitable for Small Spaces

Overflowing is an understatement with some curtains, as they all come in the same general style. This style goes beyond the frame, often leading to the floor. In cases where you have furniture below the window, these window coverings are not ideal.

Pros and Cons of Blackout Shades


Cheaper than Curtains

Due to the limited use of material, blackout shades are usually much cheaper. Reducing your costs allows you to budget a theme if you replace multiple windows. Regardless, they still let in only the amount of light you want in.

Easy to Install

Window shades’ smaller size makes them far easier to handle and install. Because they don’t go over the window, the weight limitations of your overhanging mount are less of a concern. Even if your shades work with home automation, they are still far easier to manage.

Better Automation Options

Motorized window shades are an automation addition to your household. These additions are virtually impossible with most curtains, giving shades an automatic advantage. The allowance to schedule opening and closing times for your shades can help save on energy costs. Using the heat of the sun to warm your home is far cheaper.


Weak Noise Dampening

Since you work with a smaller space and less thick materials, shades aren’t ideal for noise pollution. In some cases, people use shades or other window coverings to take advantage of multiple benefits. Regardless, shades by themselves are not usually great for keeping out sound.

Doesn’t Contain Heat as Well

Because them not covering the entire window, shades aren’t known to act as a second barrier to heat. While these window coverings are better than nothing, curtains are far better at containing heat. So if winter were the only season, curtains would be a better solution all the time.

Blackout Curtains or Shades – What is Better?

Curtains are better for containing heat, while shades are better for cost-effectiveness and advanced features. But your needs should be priority one.

To find out which option is better for you, ask yourself these questions:

  • Do I have significant window leaks?
  • Is noise pollution an issue?
  • What do I want my room to look like?
  • Do you want a smart home? (i.e., automated lights for home, blinds, etc.)
  • How easily do I want maintenance to be?

Providing answers to these questions will narrow down what option is better for you. Once you understand where your home will most benefit, you will be more comfortable selecting appropriate window covering.

Wrapping Up – Why Should You Buy Blackout Curtains or Shades?

In the battle of blackout shades vs curtains, having a preference comes down to what you need. The natural light you want in your room can change the room’s mood. Darker rooms result in more relaxation.

On the other hand, having tinted light through non-blackout window coverings can be excellent. Whatever you choose, make sure you pick something that fits your ideal home environment.